Emerson College is a cute, little private college in the middle of downtown Boston which is known for concentrating on programs that deliver quality education in communication and the arts. The tuition and fees are more than 50 grand a year, so the student body isn’t comprised for the most part of kids from nearby inner-city neighborhoods like Dorchester or the South End.
One of its programs, on the other hand, is a unique and enterprising look at a condition of life which is typical of what goes on in Dorchester and the South End of Boston, as well as in other inner-city neighborhoods all over the United States.
I’m talking about a program called the Engagement Lab, which creates multimedia featuring a collaboration with community organizations that focus on issues of importance to these organizations and groups, one of which is the issue of gun violence. If there’s another college or university in the United States which has inculcated gun violence into its curriculum, it’s news to me.
The program at Emerson is a collaboration between the college and two other organizations which play important roles in trying to respond to gun violence on Boston’s inner-city streets. One of Emerson’s partners in this effort is the Center for Gun Violence Prevention at Mass. General Hospital which promotes safety in the home through clinical care and education. The other is the Louis D. Brown Peace Institute, a community-based organization founded by the mother of a teenager who was gunned down in 1993 on his way to a meeting of a group called Teens Against Gun Violence, believe it or not.
Both of these groups are highlighted briefly in a new and provocative video created by Emerson’s Engagement Lab which is called Quiet Rooms and can be viewed right here.
The video, which runs some 20 minutes plus, is basically a compilation of first-hand narratives of parents who sat in a Boston hospital waiting to be told whether their child was going to survive the heroic attempts of a trauma team to keep the victim alive after being shot by a gun. The term ‘quiet room,’ is how physicians in these hospitals refer to the room where parents, relatives and friends of a shooting victim have to sit and wait for what is often the worst news.
This video is hardly an amateur production. The images are sharp, the dialog is clear, and most of all, the music which plays in the background sets and completely underscores the mood. And what is the mood or what we usually refer to as the ‘message’ of this film? The message is that the families which suddenly lose a child or an adult to gun violence, are totally unprepared to deal with the event, and the resources which they need to help them through this terrible and tragic event are few and far between.
This is a different perspective than the one which is usually connected to gun violence, because there are many studies, anecdotal and evidence-based, which look at the individuals who are killed or wounded with a gun. In general terms, for homicide and aggravated assault, which together count for at least 100,000 hospital- ER admissions every year, we know the victims are mostly male, mostly minority, mostly residents of inner-city neighborhoods, mostly without jobs and mostly not in school.
But the point of the Quiet Rooms video is that the person who’s brought to the ER with a bullet in his or her body isn’t the only victim of a gun assault. The people sitting in that quiet room waiting for the trauma surgeon to tell them what’s what are also victims of the same assault. And the way they are sometimes treated makes them feel like the perpetrator of a gun-violence event.
I only hope that the Emerson Engagement Lab makes a follow-up video to Quiet Rooms which focuses on the testimonies of family and friends of shooting victims who explain how they and the injured or dead family member dealt with gun violence before the individual lying on a gurney down the hall was shot.
Because gun violence doesn’t just pop up out of nowhere, the way someone gets bit by a mosquito or a tic. Half the time that someone is murdered with a gun, they actually committed the behavior which created a conflict with someone else who happened at that moment to be carrying a gun.
The only way to make a substantial dent in gun violence numbers is to deal with its causes proactively, not after the violence takes place. Emerson’s Engagement Lab states that its goal is to “transform the narratives of gun violence.”
The Quiet Rooms video is a great first step. I hope they will take the next step soon.
And by the way, send them a donation when you get a chance. And don’t tell me how you’re broke because of what the mainstream media says is the ‘ruinous inflation.’ The latest inflation rate is 8.3%. Give me a friggin’ break, okay?
May 12, 2022 @ 20:03:52
The provocative video created by Emerson’s Engagement Lab called Quiet Rooms is very interesting and as I watched and listened very closely to the words of those who have suffered the loss of a loved one it moved me to research the details behind most of those deaths. Something I found standard and normal in all these cases…gangs.
In 2021 there were 40 homicides in Boston, close to a historic low. This all occurred while homicide rates nationally rose by 30 percent in 2020. Why is that…is Boston doing something right?
Annually, gang violence generates about half of the homicides in Boston.
To help with reducing the rate of homicides in Boston a gang database was created, Boston Regional Intelligence Center Gang Database, to assist in a policing strategy that would focus on deterrence. The goal is to eliminate those who may be misguided and focus on high-risk individuals to stop further violence through law enforcement, social services, and community-based action.
Media, electronic as well as print, report that a disproportionate of people living in high-crime neighborhoods are stopped and questioned by police more than those living in more affluent neighborhoods. Will having a gang database lessen the disproportionate stopping and questioning of those who live in high-crime neighborhoods? It would be nice to have someone like, maybe the CDC, who has now gotten money for research to examine questions like this.
There have been studies similar to this, like what effect the “banning the box” had on employers from asking job applicants about their criminal histories.
I believe every major U.S. city, needs to have a gang database. If there were a gang database in every major U.S. city and properly used, gang activity could be dealt with quickly and efficiently by using the RICO Act.
However, as the Boston database showed, non-whites made up the majority of the data. This cannot happen as it would deem invidious discrimination against non-whites. Police officers already are aware of who the criminals are, and those responsible for the violent crimes that are happening every day. But the courts have found this to be ‘profiling.’ So, let’s not let police act of that which they know.
As the federal appeals court cited “flaws in that database, including its reliance on an erratic point system built on unsubstantiated inferences.” and a number of city councilors and community groups continue to call for its outright abolishment. Some of the reasons include, costly to operate, ineffective, racially unjust, and runs afoul of individuals’ civil liberties. So, I don’t believe this gang database will be around much longer.
It is unfortunate, but as Boston has found, knowing and identifying gang members and the gang community works in helping to reduce violence.
P.S. Once again, Louis D. Brown was 15-year-old in 1993, and was caught in a fatal crossfire shootout near his home. He was on his way to a “Teens Against Gang Violence” not “Teens Against Gun Violence.” Words do matter — as Barack Obama himself told us, back in 2008.
May 14, 2022 @ 10:43:36
I don’t understand this sentence: Teens Against Gang Violence” not “Teens Against Gun Violence.”
May 14, 2022 @ 14:34:58
In the post you wrote that Louis D. Brown was “…on his way to a meeting of a group called Teens Against Gun Violence, believe it or not.” This is not true. It was not only reported by the media, but also his mother Tina Chery, that Louis D. Brown was on his way to an after-school Christmas party for Teens Against Gang Violence (not gun violence). Some may say this is a small thing, but it’s not. Many know that there is a strong correlation between gang membership and criminality supported by empirical research. To say that Brown was going to meet with a group called Teens Against Gun Violence is simply misleading.
How Do We Reduce Gun Violence? |
May 14, 2022 @ 10:50:15